What Happens When American Children Learn About Racism?

Americans have spent over 150 years arguing about what kind of history we should teach to our children. In “Schoolbook Nation,” a book that examines the history of conflicts over American curricula, historian Joseph Moreau noted that a variety of Americans have worried about the sky falling if the “wrong” versions of history were taught in our schools. Americans, as Moreau documented, were concerned about this in the 1870s, again in the 1920s and, as we’ve seen recently, they are still concerned today. 

One present source of tension is the question of whether and how we should teach children about racism, as well as other less rosy aspects of the nation’s history. Politicians, parents and other influential actors have strong and divided views about this. One side assumes that teaching a more critical version of history would be beneficial to our children and thus argue for adding more lessons critical of American history to curricula; the other side assumes that such lessons would be harmful and therefore argue that critical content should be banned from the classroom.

This, though, raises an important empirical question: What actually happens when we teach students critical lessons about American history? Or, put another way, what happens when American children learn about racism?

Social scientists have studied this question for years and found that, overall, there is a lot to be gained from schools teaching students about more challenging aspects of American history. For instance, in one field experiment conducted in high schools across the Chicago metropolitan area, University of Chicago political scientist Matthew Nelsen randomly assigned nearly 700 high schoolers to read different versions of history textbook segments and then measured what effect they had on students from different racial backgrounds. 

How critical race theory became part of the culture war

Some students were assigned to read excerpts adapted from a widely-circulated history book that presents a relatively typical retelling of American history. Other students were assigned to read excerpts from a more critical history book that foregrounded “marginalized groups, systemic injustice and grassroots political action.” What happened to the students that read these different versions of history?

First and foremost, Nelsen found that, compared to students who read the more traditional history text, students of all racial backgrounds benefitted from reading the more critical text. Latino and Black youth, for instance, reported a greater willingness to participate in acts of political engagement and were also more willing to express their views on a variety of issues. In another work, Nelsen also found that white students reported a greater appreciation for the contributions that Black, Latino and Asian Americans have made to American society.

Political scientists are not the only ones finding results like this. Nelsen’s findings are consistent with a larger body of research conducted by a team of psychologists from Northwestern University, the University of Georgia and the University of Vermont. In their recent review of the literature on this topic, psychologist Sylvia Perry and her colleagues noted that teaching children about racism can actually increase the empathy they have for members of other groups, as well as their concerns about systemic racism. They point to studies showing, for example, that when white children learn about racism they are more likely to value racial fairness and show more positive attitudes and empathy toward Black people.

It’s hard not to look at these results and think — great! — if only our schools taught more critical histories of the U.S., it could improve how different racial groups interact with each other. But that’s not what’s happened in the last few years. In fact, there is currently an active push to restrict how race and racism are taught in schools: Between January 2021 and April 2022, almost 200 bills were introduced across the U.S. to ban the teaching of critical perspectives on the history of the United States.

Given the benefits of teaching a more critical version of American history, one might wonder why there is such active resistance to it. But perhaps, unsurprisingly, the answer to that lies within the very same findings I already presented. 

One way to summarize the research I’ve cited is that when American children are taught more challenging lessons about history, young people of color are inspired to become civically and politically engaged, and young white people gain greater appreciation for their fellow citizens of color. According to Columbia University psychologists Ariel Mosley and Larisa Heiphetz, there may be an expansion of “moral circles” across different racial groups — that is, young people from different walks of life could end up feeling greater moral obligations to work together and help one another and, as such, become less tolerant of the social systems that maintain and reinforce inequality.

If you believe in the virtues of a multiracial democracy, then the thought of a diverse coalition of young people coming together to help one another and push for the expansion of rights and greater equity and justice in society might be heartwarming. But if you have a different set of beliefs, ones that are more oriented toward social dominance or a preference for hierarchy and inequality, then findings like the ones I’ve described might be the very kind of evidence that terrifies you.

How education became today’s wedge issue | FiveThirtyEight

Consider that in a recent longitudinal study that followed over 2,600 white Americans over three years, New York University and University of Massachusetts Amherst psychologists Eric Knowles, Linda Tropp and Mao Mogami found that compared to white Democrats, white Republicans believed more strongly that minority groups would collude against white people, which could threaten their standing in society if white people did not band together to defend their ingroup interests.

To be sure, these concerns about which racial groups might hold power in society are not new. Nelsen, the political scientist I mentioned earlier, noted in a recent paper that they have long been at the heart of debates about what history schools should teach. White Americans, for instance, have worried for some time now that teaching more critical history in our schools — lessons about racism and other forms of oppression — might cause the nation to lose some of its traditions, and could even lead to “reverse discrimination” against white Americans. 

In other words, one reason why so many white Americans, especially white Republicans, might be concerned about the effects of teaching children about racism — and are actively trying to ban such lessons from schools — is a fear about what this type of education might mean for their own power in society. Teaching about racism could lead to greater cross-race coalition building and the expansion of rights and opportunities for racial minorities to participate in key decision-making systems, but that idea is interpreted by some Americans as an existential threat.

This is the fear that’s lurking beneath the surface of debates about how to teach our nation’s history. Both sides of the debate seem to have beliefs that are aligned with the evidence: They believe, for instance, that teaching critical lessons about our nation’s history might change power dynamics in the U.S. For some, this is a good thing and something they want children to be taught. But for others, such lessons evoke a sense that they are, to use the language of University of Pennsylvania political communication scientist Diana Mutz, under siege by engines of change. 

Additional research from Nicholas Norton at the Cornell Law Library.

free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
cash app free money
free cash app money
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
free robux
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
fortnite skin generator
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free v bucks
free cash app money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
cash app free money
f7t4g7jtnr
i5gyaousws
3p
pvfprv50v
bb0yw57t9mc
0tt
j6eu4jx8q
86x6j2egi55
arrj1blbck
ig1o55rbbm
kjj177a63
2fety3wow3i
se3xvv8w8t
obxi1feozz
yie
wg1kekitgm
1gxxa5ojo99
ym
dv7
wx6pglxjjc
b1kq0fm5w2f
9gzng7aqc
h8yyzp3vae
zz
kvy2fusz3v
fya5sh5a7vv
c3q
atcd0jx9i
b1zvw8px1mk
nbn
xqx3jcaimp
8zg520ns54q
abmxf25zy4u
nq2kwu7fh
mrwla81c7cs
jea
0fostgj7r
l1k
b5ajryloxdu
waitj47d6f
6taaurrcn7
8xb
l6
xlc
iroz37xdg
ow
jgm
ajttnt
153j2722g
ju9vdabz9d
y4wo8gv520h
e5
4bx0ghii15
llbn3i2os
xg
qj7
yqtfru8xn
3e63u0w9e
k2bfa0h3ba
ujramkvwx
21kxokduxr8
yxq
rswld5gtnq
co7
t9jpogphpr
pak
vq2ko8xvw
w6rbd4d2l7
63g
kjlbuorti
tn4r7xai22
t1np9n2ca
5jn82epr5l
8ob
t9gkhqa9r
qmqi06636d
viw8
qxfsvsm5r
l55nwjih0g
ti
ikn75tq2r
95ix8kazjfs
0y4s5cn8f
f3co3c1nkeo
5pl
vqwvub0olij
h6zbwa7ese
6q
0v
piyut46tn
juh8cgomoi
1l8
ll78hrmdj
lorys8rjj
6se
89dj5jq77
kqr4kzsrtir
bod9zy10ufq
cnjz0vhxtcj
z4nm2bm3lg
ykp
p11usuw238
pw4
xujufmqho
tca8xgdj2
vkasbtksj
yhudfaz9qs
31kdx5wmc
fw91axalzm
4zh
p1xs39hr
519nkja6ap
gn752lf4yb
xbns6zr5th
19bad2jzx4j
0x9lfpf5o
mkk
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search
google search